• Home
  • About
  • Books
  • The Battle of Cowpens
    • Cavalry
    • Artillery
    • Infantry
  • Musketry
  • Napoleon vs. Washington
    • Introduction
    • Historical Context
    • Tactics
    • Strategy: Napoleon
    • Strategy: Washington
    • Leadership

Twistification

~ All Things Revolutionary War

Twistification

Tag Archives: guns germs and steel

Guns, Germs and Steel

04 Saturday Apr 2015

Posted by Twistification in Uncategorized

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

civilization, culture, guns germs and steel

Guns, Germs and Steel by Jared Diamond

Guns, Germs and Steel by Jared Diamond

Why do some civilizations become more technologically advanced than others? What leads to the rise of empires and to the dissolution of native peoples? This is often a loaded question that can reveal a persons prejudice. It is a question that is generally not explored or even contemplated by most members of our “modern society”.

Jared Diamond takes a scientific and historical approach to this controversial topic. Guns Germs and Steel takes and in depth look into the circumstances that give rise to dominant peoples and civilizations.

Lets take a (somewhat oversimplified) look at what it takes to become a empire from the ground up…

1: Start with enough wild plant diversity that the benefits of domesticating these plants outweigh the benefits of hunting gathering.

This requires an assortment plants that when domesticated, provide excess calories. The fertile crescent provides this appropriate mix with its wild cereals and grains.

domesticated animals2: Be sure the native animals can be domesticated.

These animals will then help provide additional calories (such as pigs and cows) as well as assist in farming (like ox and horses). Not many animals on the earth can be domesticated. Around the time homo sapiens migrated to North America, animals that potentially could be domesticated were wiped out. These animals did not evolve along side mankind, and therefore had no adequate defense mechanisms to stave off extinction at the hands of these clever interlopers.

3: Resistance to disease is not futile–it is essential. 

Keep calm and avoid the plague

Keep calm and avoid the plague

Sharing viruses and bacteria with domesticated animals will produce unique diseases that only your people will be able to develop resistance. This will take some time and many losses on your side, but eventually natural selection will take over and weed out the susceptible members of your civilization.

Exposing rival peoples to these diseases will wipe out your competitors and leave room to successfully migrate to other lands. This unintended “asset” will be your primary means of establishing dominance peoples unexposed to nasties such as tuberculosis, small pox, the plague, and the flu to name a few.

4: Live in the ‘Goldilocks’ of geography–not too isolated, but not too connected.

Your geography needs to be free of signification obstructions from east to west. This allows farming technology to migrate with a little climate change as possible. North south migration is much more difficult because significant changes in climate make it harder for domesticated crops to adjust or even survive.

The goldilocks of geography must also provide enough barriers to create competing–but still connected–pockets of peoples.

Too many geographical barriers? Your people become isolated and may not feel the pressure from nearby competitors to advance in military and food producing technology.

Too few geographical barriers? Your people could be conquered and fall under an authoritarian rule that may resist technological and geographical advances due lack of nearby competition (China).

5. Feel the pressure to keep up with the Joneses. 

Hello Japan. Have we showed you our cannons yet?

Hello Japan. Have we showed you our cannons yet?

Competition from your rivals will force you stay on edge. You cannot afford to take principled stances against technology that rubs your religious or societal sensibilities the wrong way. Adapt or be conquered.

Japan is a unique case study. Japans’ geographical isolation allowed them to throw out superior rifle technology and maintain an antiquated military technology until US gunships showed up on their shores in 1853.

Conclusion

Notably absent from this list is “have more geniuses” or “get capitalism” or “be culturally innovative” or even more wrongheaded assumptions like “genetics”. The primary point is that civilizations benefit first and foremost from circumstance. This may be a hard truth for those who feel that work ethic, cultural intelligence or a particular social system to be a primary factor. These factors are of some significance, but not nearly as much as the factors listed above.

Recent Posts

  • Militia Cavalry
  • Road to Guilford Courthouse
  • With Musket & Tomahawk
  • Long time no post, but updates coming
  • Hunting Frock

Categories

  • 1777 Charleville
  • 4th of July
  • Alexander Hamilton
  • AMC
  • Banastre Tarleton
  • Black Powder
  • Black Powder Firearms
  • Bunker Hill
  • Cavalry
  • Charles Lee
  • Charleston
  • Columbus
  • Cornwallis
  • Cowpens
  • Daniel Morgan
  • documentary
  • Duel
  • Founding Fathers
  • Gear
  • George Washington
  • Gerstner
  • Gettysburg
  • Gun Room
  • Infantry
  • King George III
  • Memorial Day
  • Musket
  • Napoleon Bonaparte
  • Nathaniel Greene
  • National Infantry Museum
  • Reboubt
  • reenactment
  • Revolutionary War
  • Rochambeau
  • Slavery
  • Spontoon
  • Stephen Decatur
  • Strategy & Tactics
  • The battle of Cowpens
  • The Battle of the Hook
  • Thomas Paine
  • TURN
  • Uncategorized
  • War of 1812
  • Waterloo
  • Weapons of the Revolution
  • Whiskey Rebellion
  • Yorktown

Blogs I Follow

  • Get The Picture
  • Laura Lee Living
  • TURN to a historian
  • john pavlovitz
  • Swungover*
  • wbahr
  • 43andfatfree Blog
  • this is... The Neighborhood
  • Twistification
  • That's What She Said
  • Past in the Present
  • TrappersWildWest
  • A Woodsrunner's Diary
  • The Long Roll
  • Journal of the American Revolution

Recent Comments

Fawn Gero on ‘The Revenant’ is…
IAC on Cartridge Making Day!
wbahr on Cartridge Making Day!
Immortan joe on Myths of the Revolution: …
Twistification on Questions for an Artiller…

Recent Comments

Fawn Gero on ‘The Revenant’ is…
IAC on Cartridge Making Day!
wbahr on Cartridge Making Day!
Immortan joe on Myths of the Revolution: …
Twistification on Questions for an Artiller…

Blog at WordPress.com.

Get The Picture

Bloviation for the Dawgnation

Laura Lee Living

Experiences in Life & Kitchen

TURN to a historian

Has "TURN: Washington's Spies" left you feeling a little... spy-curious?

john pavlovitz

Stuff That Needs To Be Said

Swungover*

wbahr

4 out of 5 dentists are pulling for me!

43andfatfree Blog

in 2002 I decided to share my weight loss journey! Its been a life struggle. I hope this site helps others who deal with emotional eating!

this is... The Neighborhood

the Story within the Story

Twistification

All Things Revolutionary War

That's What She Said

Clearly, I take myself seriously.

Past in the Present

Blogging American History--News, Books, Museums, Sites, and More

TrappersWildWest

Historian. Artist. Gunmaker.

A Woodsrunner's Diary

All Things Revolutionary War

The Long Roll

Discussions about the American Civil War (1861-1865)

Journal of the American Revolution

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Twistification
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Twistification
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...